bannerbckground

He Who Is Without Sin

To understand why Christians believe Jesus is without sin, start with the fact that Christianity is based on a religion of blood sacrifice. The ancient Hebrews lived in terror of a God who descended on them in fire and smoke at Mt. Sinai. The Lord Most High established a covenant with them that demanded absolute obedience to his Law under penalty of death. Transgressions against God could only be appeased through the shedding of blood — either one’s own or the blood of another living thing. Since the shedding of one’s own blood was presumably something to be avoided, animals were sacrificed in the temple instead to atone for sin. Temple priests in Jerusalem practiced an elaborate system of animal sacrifices on behalf of sinners to satisfy the demand for blood.

Christians replaced animal sacrifice with the belief that Christ’s death represented a “full, perfect and sufficient sacrifice for the sins of the whole world.”* They regarded Christ as being without sin, a “lamb without blemish,” in accordance with the Old Testament requirement that sacrificial animals must be without defect. But how was this possible? If Jesus was fully human and “in every respect has been tempted as we are,” how could he remain unblemished?

That issue was hotly debated in the early church. Was Jesus God, a man or some combination of the two? A fourth-century priest in Alexandria named Arius argued that Jesus was more than man, but less than God. As to whether Jesus was without sin, Arius cited chapter and verse to prove that Jesus did not regard himself as being on the same footing as God. In the Gospel of Matthew (17:19 KJV) he responds when addressed as “good master:” “Why callest thou me good? there is none good but one, that is, God…” Arius’ opponents cited numerous scriptural references of their own to make the case that Jesus was without sin. In a bid for church unity, the fourth-century Roman Emperor Constantine convened a church council at Nicaea in Asia Minor to settle the matter. In their wisdom, the assembled prelates decided to split the difference and decreed that Jesus was both fully human and fully divine. Arius, who attended the council, found himself betwixt and between and was declared a heretic.

The Nicaean formulation played off Jesus’ dual nature to address some of the more vexing theological problems arising from his unique status. How could he be fully human and yet not sin? Well, he was the Son of God. How could he be the Son of God and yet die? Well, he was human. There is a kind of circularity to this argument that still leaves us wondering what to make of him. The author of the Book of Hebrews described him as “holy, innocent, undefiled, separated from sinners and exalted above the heavens.” Jesus is supposed to be one of us, and yet who knows anyone like that? He was the Son of God who dazzled everyone with his miraculous actions and yet could not save himself from a grisly death. He appeared to be neither fully human nor fully divine.

The Nicene Creed hammered out at the Council of Nicaea declared that Jesus was the “only begotten” Son of God, which is commonly interpreted to mean he was the only one of his kind. But did Jesus actually think of himself that way? Not long after he offended Jews gathered at the temple in Jerusalem by proclaiming, “I and the Father are one,” Jesus prayed that his followers “may all be one; even as thou, Father, art in me, and I in thee, that they also may be in us.”·

Suddenly the issue is no longer who Jesus was but who we are. “You are gods,” Jesus told a hostile crowd that was preparing to stone him for blasphemy. He wasn’t just saying this to throw them off balance. He was quoting one of the Psalms that reads in part, "I say, you are gods, children of the Most High all of you." This certainly does not sound like someone who regarded himself as having an exclusive franchise. Later, St. Paul would describe Jesus as being the “first-born among many brethren.” (Presumably that would also include sisteren.) What did that mean for us? The implications are mind-blowing. But alas, the Nicaean Creed has nothing to say about that.

*As expressed in the Anglican Book of Common Prayer.

Hebrews 7:26
John 10:30
John 17:21
Psalm 82:6

Home

www.godwardweb.org
© Copyright 2004-2025 by Eric Rennie
All Rights Reserved